How to check and dispute First Step Act time credits
Short answer: The Bureau of Prisons (BOP) records First Step Act time credits on an FSA Time Credit Assessment, also called an FTC Worksheet. If the person in custody thinks the credits are wrong, BOP policy points to the Administrative Remedy Program: informal resolution, then forms BP-9, BP-10 and BP-11, each with its own deadline.
By OutSooner editorial team · Last checked Nov 3, 2026
Step 1: Get the FSA Time Credit Assessment
BOP policy says FTC Worksheets are uploaded automatically to the Inmate Central File each time credits are auto-calculated. The person gets a copy of the most recent worksheet at regularly scheduled program reviews. (Source: BOP Program Statement 5410.01 CN-2, Section 8 ↗ (opens in new tab))
Step 2: Compare the worksheet with the rules
These are the points the rules cover. They are questions to compare against the worksheet, not a finding that anything is wrong.
- Rate: 10 days of credit for every 30 days of successful participation in recommended programs or productive activities, plus 5 more days per 30 days if BOP rates the person minimum or low risk and that rating held over the two most recent consecutive assessments. (Source: 28 CFR 523.42(c) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Start date: credits begin after the term of imprisonment commences. No credit is earned for programming before December 21, 2018. (Source: 28 CFR 523.42(a)-(b) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Periods that usually don't count: the rule says a person generally isn't "successfully participating" while in a Special Housing Unit, designated outside the institution (for example a hospital stay, escorted trip or furlough), temporarily in another agency's custody, on a mental health or psychiatric hold, or opted out. (Source: 28 CFR 523.41(c)(4) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Opting out: a choice not to take part must be documented by staff, and it stops further FSA benefits until the date the person opts back in, as documented by staff. (Source: 28 CFR 523.41(c)(5) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Interruptions: temporary operational or program interruptions authorized by BOP will not ordinarily affect successful participation. (Source: 28 CFR 523.41(c)(3) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Eligibility: people serving a sentence for an offense listed in 18 U.S.C. 3632(d)(4)(D) can't earn credits. (Source: 28 CFR 523.41(d)(2) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Applying credits: BOP may apply credits only when they equal the rest of the term and the risk-rating conditions are met (for prerelease custody, a Warden-approved petition can take the place of the two low-risk assessments). (Source: 28 CFR 523.44(c)(2) ↗ (opens in new tab)) Transfer to supervised release can come no earlier than 12 months before it otherwise would. Credits can't be applied for a person with a final order of removal. (Source: 28 CFR 523.44(a)-(d) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Detainers: BOP policy says people with unresolved pending charges or detainers may earn credits but can't apply them until those are resolved. Unresolved immigration status is treated the same way. (Source: BOP Program Statement 5410.01 CN-2, Section 10 ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Lost credits: credits may be lost for violating program rules, under the discipline procedures in 28 CFR part 541. They may be restored, in part or in full, case by case, after clear conduct for two consecutive risk and needs assessments. (Source: 28 CFR 523.43(a), (c) ↗ (opens in new tab))
To see the sentence math next to the credit estimate, use our First Step Act calculator. It is an estimate only. BOP calculates the credits.
Step 3: Try informal resolution with staff
The rules say the person first raises the issue informally with staff, and staff try to resolve it before a formal request. People in community corrections centers (halfway houses) don't have to try informal resolution. The Warden or the institution's Administrative Remedy Coordinator may waive it for an acceptable reason. (Source: 28 CFR 542.13 ↗ (opens in new tab))
BOP policy also describes a separate request: a person rated minimum or low risk who hasn't yet had two consecutive assessments at that level submits a BP-A0148, Inmate Request to Staff, during a regularly scheduled program review to have early application of credits considered. The Warden or a designee makes the final decision. (Source: BOP Program Statement 5410.01 CN-2, Section 10 ↗ (opens in new tab))
Step 4: File a BP-9 with the Warden
- Deadline: informal resolution and the BP-9 must be completed within 20 calendar days after the date the basis for the request occurred. An extension may be allowed for a valid reason for delay, such as a long time in transit away from needed papers, or an unusually long informal resolution attempt. (Source: 28 CFR 542.14(a)-(b) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Form: get it from institution staff, ordinarily the correctional counselor. Put one complaint, or a reasonable number of closely related issues, on each form. Up to one letter-size continuation page is allowed, plus one copy of supporting exhibits. Exhibits aren't returned, so keep copies. (Source: 28 CFR 542.14(c) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Sensitive issues: if the person reasonably believes their safety or well-being would be in danger if the request became known at the institution, they may send it directly to the Regional Director, marked "Sensitive" with a written reason. If the regional coordinator doesn't agree it's sensitive, it isn't accepted, and the person may file it with the Warden, who must allow a reasonable extension of time. (Source: 28 CFR 542.14(d)(1) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Emergencies: if the request is an emergency that threatens the person's immediate health or welfare, the Warden must respond by the third calendar day after filing. (Source: 28 CFR 542.18 ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Response time: the Warden responds within 20 calendar days of filing. That can be extended once by 20 days, with written notice. (Source: 28 CFR 542.18 ↗ (opens in new tab))
Step 5: Appeal: BP-10, then BP-11
- BP-10 to the Regional Director: within 20 calendar days of the date the Warden signed the response, with a complete copy of the BP-9 and its response. (Source: 28 CFR 542.15 ↗ (opens in new tab))
- BP-11 to the General Counsel: within 30 calendar days of the date the Regional Director signed the response. This is the final administrative appeal. If the person shows a valid reason for delay, these appeal time limits may be extended. (Source: 28 CFR 542.15(a) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Same issues only: an appeal can't raise issues that weren't raised at the lower level. (Source: 28 CFR 542.15(b)(2) ↗ (opens in new tab))
- Response times: Regional Director 30 calendar days, General Counsel 40. Each may be extended once, by 30 days at the regional level and 20 days at the Central Office, with written notice. If no response comes within the time allowed, including any extension, the person may treat it as a denial at that level. (Source: 28 CFR 542.18 ↗ (opens in new tab))
If credits were taken away in a disciplinary case
The rule says review of lost FSA time credits goes through the Administrative Remedy Program. Appeals of a Discipline Hearing Officer (DHO) decision are filed first with the Regional Director for the region where the person is held, not with the Warden. Each incident report number is appealed on its own form. (Source: 28 CFR 523.43(b) ↗ (opens in new tab)) (Source: 28 CFR 542.14(c)(2), (d)(2) ↗ (opens in new tab))
What family members can do
Family members and attorneys may help the person prepare a request or appeal, but no one may submit it for them. Getting help isn't a valid reason for missing a deadline unless staff caused the delay. (Source: 28 CFR 542.16(a) ↗ (opens in new tab)) Former inmates may use the program for issues that arose while they were confined. (Source: 28 CFR 542.10(b) ↗ (opens in new tab))
Step-by-step form details: Federal (BOP) grievance process (BP-9/10/11).
Questions families ask
Where can someone see their First Step Act time credits?
BOP policy says FSA Time Credit Assessments (FTC Worksheets) are uploaded to the Inmate Central File at each auto-calculation, and the person gets a copy of the most recent worksheet at regularly scheduled program reviews (BOP Program Statement 5410.01).
How is a disagreement about FSA time credits raised?
BOP Program Statement 5410.01 says any issue relating to it may be raised through the Administrative Remedy Program in 28 CFR part 542: informal resolution with staff, then a BP-9 request to the Warden, a BP-10 appeal to the Regional Director and a BP-11 appeal to the General Counsel.
What is the deadline for a BP-9?
Under 28 CFR 542.14(a), informal resolution and the BP-9 must be completed within 20 calendar days after the date the basis for the request occurred. An extension may be allowed for a valid reason for delay (542.14(b)).
Can a family member file for the person?
No. Under 28 CFR 542.16(a), family members and attorneys may help prepare a request or appeal, but no one may submit it on the person's behalf.
This page describes the steps the rules set out. It can't say how BOP will decide any request. General information, not legal advice.
Related
Sources
- 28 CFR part 523, subpart E (FSA time credits, 523.40-44) (opens in new tab)
- 28 CFR part 542, subpart B (Administrative Remedy Program) (opens in new tab)
- BOP Program Statement 5410.01 CN-2: First Step Act Time Credits (PDF) (opens in new tab)
- BOP Program Statement 1330.18: Administrative Remedy Program (PDF) (opens in new tab)
Where BOP policy and the current rule differ, the rule controls.
Last checked Nov 3, 2026.
How we verified this page
- Sources checked: the official sources linked here were last checked on the date below.
- Rules compared: our explanation is compared with those sources. It is not a legal review or legal advice.
- Errors: if anything doesn't match the official source, tell us on the Corrections page.
Sources: 28 CFR 523 subpart E (opens in new tab) · 28 CFR 542 subpart B (opens in new tab) · Last verified: · Corrections
Methodology · Data quality · Privacy · Editorial & source review
General information, not legal advice. OutSooner is not a law firm or a government agency. Laws and rules change; check the official source linked on each page before you act. Full disclaimer →